Jump to content

2.1: Defining Mentor Text

From KNILT

Return to:

Authentic Text as Writing Mentors | Unit 2: Mentor Texts

Learning Objective

Participants will define “Mentor Text.”

Engage

Have you ever worked with a coach or a mentor before? Think about your relationship with that person. How did they help you improve? What kind of support did they provide? Jot down your reflections on scratch paper.

Learn

Writing is a socially contextualized, communicative process; it is both the way that we permanently record and share ideas as well as a means of "thinking on paper" to refine understanding. When we teach process writing, a strong place to start is using a model to build students' understanding of genre, purpose, form, and audience. To support this need, publishers have included contrived "student models" in text books and teachers have written models themselves or saved student exemplars from previous years. While these model essays have value, analogous reflection may help to further assess their application.

Consider the language domain matrix:

From English Club

Language is divided into two binaries: receptive/productive and oral/written. Receptive skills (or inputs) are when people take in information from language and productive skills (or outputs) are when people convey information through language. Oral (or spoken) language includes speaking and listening while written language covers reading and writing.

A research-backed consensus exists in classrooms today, especially Reading and ELA, that rich, authentic texts are critical for reading and comprehension instruction (receptive written quadrant). Leveled or decodable (contrived) texts are generally reserved for pre-literate and intervention instruction. Why then, would educators not want to provide the same high quality authentic models for the reciprocal skill (productive written quadrant), rather than the contrived models currently in use?

Furthermore, a substantial body of research on authentic mentor texts has grown in the fields of English as a Foreign Language (EFL) and English as a Second Language (ESL) because mentor texts provide not only an imitable example, but also the social context necessary to be successful while writing in a given genre.

Read this blog post from the Iowa Reading Research Center to explore the definition and practical use of mentor texts in the classroom.

Practice

Use this quiz to check your understanding.

Apply

Is there a text in your unit plan or outline that is the same genre as your unit writing task? If not, is there a genre-aligned text that would fit well in the unit? Does the text meet the criteria outlined in Lesson 2.1? Post your reflection in the 2.1 Reflection column on the digital bulletin board.

Next: 2.2: Evaluating Mentor Texts