2.2: Evaluating Mentor Texts
Return to:
Authentic Text as Writing Mentors | Unit 2: Mentor Texts
Learning Objective
Participants will reflect on the qualities to look for in an authentic mentor text.
Engage
What tools do you use to evaluate something? A rubric? A T-Chart? A spreadsheet? Do you evaluate some things differently than others (a movie v. a student paper, for example)? Jot down your reflections on scratch paper.
Learn
The blog post from Lesson 2.1 began to describe the process for evaluating a mentor text and will continue to be a valuable resource for this lesson.
Read the Writing by Ear and Mentor and Guide sections (pages 14-18) from Turner, 2014.
Because the end goal of a writing mentor is to provide students with something they can emulate based on analysis of its audience, purpose, literacy genre legacy, defining features, and language features (recall the 6 Traits of Writing alignment), a good mentor text should be a good representative of its genre.
Practice
Imagine that you are planning a thematic unit on mythology for Grade 7 ELA. Your unit writing task is an narrative essay with the prompt
Write a myth based on an original pantheon, hero, or culture to explain a natural phenomenon. Your narrative should have a clear beginning, middle, and end, use figurative language as appropriate, and shed light on the values of your original pantheon, hero, or culture.
As you search for a version of "The Flight of Icarus" to use as a mentor text, you find the following options:
- "The Flight of Icarus" a myth retold by Sally Benson
- "The Flight of Icarus" from Myths and Legends
- "The Myth of Daedalus and Icarus" from Greek Myths & Greek Mythology
Which of these texts would best serve as a writing mentor? Why? Use this organizer as a guide as you evaluate.
Apply
What are the audience, purpose, literary genre legacy, defining features, and language features for the genre of your unit's writing task? Once you have generic expectations, review genre-aligned texts in your unit plan or outline. What are some specific examples of your generic expectations? Post your reflection in the 2.2 Reflection column on the digital bulletin board.
Next: Unit 3: Preparing for Unit Planning with a Mentor Text