Jump to content

Lesson 2.1: Introduction to Social Annotations

From KNILT
<<<Unit 2 Overview||| Next Lesson (2.2)>>>

Objective and Materials

  • Objective: Identify features that make up the Social Annotations model.
    • Examine Case Study #1 to determine which scenario presented may best suit the Social Annotation model.
  • Materials: Personal Journal, sectioned and labeled Lesson 2.1 Notes

Task 1: Spark Your Thinking

Social Annotations provide one method to deepen the level of engagement between students and the class community at large. It is proven that shared reading within a classroom has a multitude of benefits. In "What are the Benefits of Shared Reading for Primary and Intermediate Students?" from the Heinmann Blog, there are some the cited advantages to creating a community of connected readers; "Shared reading helps young readers understand the relationship between oral language and print". The article continues by describing the importance of 'play' in reading, ability to increase the rigor and challenge of reading for students, and improvement in comprehension, phonics and vocabulary.

Review the article cited above, "What are the Benefits of Shared Reading for Primary and Intermediate Students?":

  1. After reading the article, jot down 1-2 personal goals that you have for your students as readers.
  2. Have you ever created a community space where students can read, write, or even annotate together? How can this be helpful for students?

Task 2: Social Annotations Overview

Sarah McDaniel, in "Social Annotation and the Pedagogy of Hypothe.sis" introduces the annotation model as "Social annotation, the process of highlighting, marking up, and zooming in on the component parts of a text in the company of classmates and colleagues, forms an integral part of many instructors’ pedagogical practice in the humanities or social sciences classroom. Whether oriented toward a goal of comprehension, translation, formal or historical analysis, or revision, these communal acts of reading closely together often represent the cornerstone of pedagogies of interpretation and analysis – and, additionally, are frequently remembered with fondness by instructors and students alike as moments of keen insight and illumination"[1].

It's important to note that Social Annotations is a restructuring of common annotation practices, that seeks to allow students the ability to contribute to each other's understanding, and build on each other's thinking directly on a text, through conversation. Digital tools are now inextricably linked to the annotation model, because many educators and researchers are creating platforms that allow for learners to engage with one another while looking at a document or text.

As the article continues, some of the potential uses of this annotation practice include:

  • "sharpening interpretive practices"
  • "honing rhetoric and craft"
  • "developing fluency in the methods or meta-discourses of a new field"
  • "deepening students’ understanding of works’ stakes and intertextual resonances"[1]

Some of the most important uses for ELA classrooms at the middle-grade level would include community reading and writing activities, such as close reading, text analysis, student-writing revision and editing. Creating any number of ELA activities collaborative allows for students to think of reading and writing as a process, rather than as a means to an end. The methods to which students can collectively annotate and discuss reading texts are endless.

Review the article ("With Online Social Annotation, Students Read Together") in order to answer the following questions:

Write your notes in your personal journal, under the section titled "Lesson 2.1 Notes".

1) What are the benefits of Social Annotations?

2) What are the limits of Social Annotations?

Task 3: Case Study #1

Below you will read a number of scenarios, descriptive to include the student demographic and needs, skills and desired outcomes as identified by the educator, and the text that students are reading.

After reading through each of the scenarios, select any scenario and describe how it could align with an activity that includes Social Annotations. To practice accurately designing an intentional activity that would include this annotation practice, write in our discussion titled '2.1 Discussion'.

Scenarios in the ELA Classroom
Scenario #1: Ms. Walker, a fifth-grade ELA teacher, is designing a unit of Informational Articles and Non-Fiction texts for her students. She has a classroom population of 10 students, many of whom are not on reading level. Ms. Walker has 2 ENL students as well, who speak Spanish or French. The first text of the unit be a scientific article on Energy Transformation and will include jargon and content-specific vocabulary. The desired outcome of this first reading is to introduce students to text features that would appear in an informational article.
Scenario #2: Mr. Smith, a seventh-grade ELA teacher, is designing a unit based on the novel Brown Girl Dreaming. He has a classroom population of 25 students, many of whom are reaching grade level for reading. Mr. Smith has 5 IEP students, with comprehension and processing delays. The first text excerpt will include 3 poems from the novel, and the desired outcome of this first reading is to examine the characteristics and experiences of the narrator of the poems.

Include in your writing:

  • How do you imagine a Social Annotations activity aligning with the educator's classroom and goals in the scenario you selected?
  • What reading comprehension strategies (see lesson 1.2) would you include, if you were designing such an activity?
  • How would students benefit from the collaborative aspect of Social Annotations in the scenario?

Task 4: Exit Ticket

We have looked at an overview of what Social Annotations are, and an example of how it may fit into ELA content classes.

Take a few minutes to complete the Lesson 2.1 Exit Ticket Padlet, as a check of understanding and reflection of potential uses of this particular model of annotations.

Return to this Padlet after a few days of your original post and respond to one of your peer's original posts, adding onto their thinking or providing additional insights to their work.

 <<<Unit 2 Overview||| Next Lesson (2.2)>>>

Sources