Lesson 2.2: Practice of Social Annotations
<<<Unit 2 Overview||| [[|Next Lesson (3.1)>>>]]

Objective and Materials
- Objective: Examine the experience of Social Annotations by reading specific studies conducted.
- Practice Social Annotations with classmates by engaging with a text on Google Docs.
- Materials: Personal Journal, sectioned and labeled Lesson 2.2 Notes
Task 1: Spark Your Thinking
As students, educators and learners in a progressively advancing digital age, we have all entered spaces that require some level of technology usage. As Social Annotations relies heavily on providing new spaces for students and communities to build upon their individual reading and thinking, it's important to examine what purpose digital tools serve in the classroom.
Review the screenshot below, of an example of conversation happening on a peer-reviewed education article read by college students. These students are educators of an online Education course.
Examine the following features of the image:
- The tab on the right side labeled "Current conversation" and what students are discussing as they read.
- What features of the website exemplify typical annotation strategies?
- The left side of the website, including website design.

Write in your journal, under the notes section labeled Lesson 2.2 Notes, what your initial impressions are. Organize your notes to include your thoughts on the three bullet-points above, taking careful examination of the visual layout of the student collaboration, annotations, and website layout.
Task 2: Social Annotations in ELA Classes
The pedagogical insights and implications that will further contextualize our dive into Social Annotations will derive from research-driven paper “'I Love This Insight, Mary Kate!': Social Annotation Across Two ELA Methods Classes", written by Allred, Hochstetler, and Goering and "Social Annotation and the Pedagogy of Hypothe.sis" by Sarah McDaniel. Social Annotations work best when situated in a classroom setting that honors communication and transmission of knowledge. Such classrooms may exhibit a dialogic approach to learning: "Dialogic learning, where students make comments that build upon previous comments, provides opportunities for new ways of thinking"[1] (Allred, et. al). A cornerstone of social annotations are the conversational aspect of student work. The writers continue by stating "When annotations are shared, considered, and responded to, students are better able to evaluate texts critically and build upon others’ ideas". Evaluating thinking by revising another student's annotations will allow for students to develop critical thinking.
In Allred's article, a comprehensive study was conducted using two different sets of University students that are familiar with annotation as practice, as they are students of the Education program at the University.
Read through the article 'I Love This Insight, Mary Kate!': Social Annotation Across Two ELA Methods Classes", and jot down in your journal answers related to the following prompts:
- What are two surprising anecdotal details related to the experience of the University students that engaged in Social Annotations?
- What kinds of benefits were found by the researchers following the study?
Task 3: Social Annotation Practice

Students will engage in a sample practice of Social Annotations by reading a text and leaving comments on Google Docs: Social Annotation Practice Google Doc.
The digital platform being used is a common one, Google Docs. The goal of the sample annotation practice is to:
- Practice using a digital platform to engage with a text; take note of short-comings of the the platform for annotating, and potential features that are helpful
- Engage in the conversational, knowledge-sharing aspect of Social Annotations
Leave 1-3 comments on the Google Doc, attached to specific lines that you highlight in your annotations.
After leaving your original comments, return to the Google Doc in a few days to review what comments have been left. Any annotations and comments that spark your interest, generate questions or respond to your initial posts are meant to be responded to.
Task 4: Exit Ticket
After leaving a comment and receiving a comment (give your classmates time to conduct their work, potentially a few days) take a moment to reflect on the experience of engaging in 'conversation' over a text.
Answer the following questions in your journal (prepare to engage with these responses by Lesson 4.1):
- What benefit do you see for learners engaging in Social Annotations online?
- What body of learners, in what spaces, may benefit from this specific practice of reading, annotating and engaging digitally?
- What changed for you in reading your peer's comments and seeing their annotations?
<<<Unit 2 Overview||| [[|Next Lesson (3.1)>>>]]