Lesson 1.2: Purpose and Data Behind Annotation Practices
<<<Unit 1 Overview||| Next Lesson (2.1)>>>

Objective and Materials
- Objectives:
- Determine the purpose of annotation practice and similar reading strategies.
- Materials: Personal Journal, sectioned and labeled Lesson 1.2 Notes
Task 1: Spark Your Thinking

In our previous lesson, we reflected on literal practices and techniques that are commonly used and referred to in relation to annotation practice in ELA. It is important to evaluate the purpose and goals involved in the creation of certain annotation practices. To consider the efficacy of certain practices and to further imagine how these practices may transfer onto online platforms, we will look into pedagogies and perspectives that focus on meaning-making and increasing engagement with a text.
Review the image to the right of sample student annotations of a poem.
On our online discussion forum, jot down:
1) Where did the student succeed with annotating? What suggestions would you provide to this student to push their reading?
2) What were the teacher's goals in the annotation task provided? Is it made clear and accessible to the student?
Task 2: Article Review
Comprehension strategies that are developed for ELA instruction will be a recurrent theme in the lessons as we track and reflect on the needs readers have. Most importantly, as we examine the purpose behind the design of certain annotation directives, we will return to the idea of meaning-making.
Sara Christie in her blogpost "Comprehension Strategies (Making Meaning of Texts) – Part Two" describes multiple comprehension skills needed to actively read and engage in a text as:
- Summarizing-
- Being able to tell the main events.
- Making Connections-
- Making connections to one’s own life, other stories, etc.
- Making Predictions-
- Using text clues to support an idea of what will happen next.
- Asking Questions-
- Asking questions about the content or an idea.
- Visualizing-
- Being able to describe what the characters or setting looks like in their head
- Activating Schema-
- Offering knowledge that is not included in the text during discussion.
- Inferencing-
- Being able to figure out what is happening without it being explicitly stated.
- Synthesizing-
- Identifying a lesson/theme/morale.[1]
Read and review the following two articles:
- Teaching the Long-Term Value of Annotation
- 5 Steps to Great Annotations
- In your journal, describe the most effective ways educators can design annotation usage and specific methods suggested, as described by the author. Notes in your journal should be composed in a manner that best suits you for our first unit. Consider your notes in lesson 1.2 a demonstration of your annotation style and demonstration of your thinking as a reader.
- Outstanding Question: How do typical annotation practices attempt to support comprehension of readers? How do you think annotations aim to do so?
Task 3: Video Overview
It is important to combine annotation strategies with the overarching goal of the reading. Depending on the needs of the student, goals of the unit and the knowledge previously learned, classrooms will address different reading skills with the text. Specific genres may be dependent on prerequisite skills for students to engage in deep understanding. One such example would be the understanding of text-features for non-fiction and informative articles, or the understanding of figurative language for poetry.
The video attached provides an educator's perspective and model of what text annotations look like for a fictional text. The creator of the video provides further context on the students and goals of reading: "A fourth-grade class is reading Wonder by R.J. Palacio. While Reading Part I, the students need to think about what they can infer about the character August".
Watch the video (Text Annotation by Gabrielle Leimbach) and provide your own observations on the following questions:
Write your notes and share on our discussion forum labeled "1.2 Video Discussion".
- How does the educator model annotation?
- Which comprehension strategies listed above are targeted skills, based on the model?
- How are the annotations coded or organized?
Exit Ticket
We have reviewed specific annotation purposes in connection to general comprehension reading strategies used in middle school ELA classrooms. Take a few minutes to complete the 1.2 Google Form Exit Ticket, as a check of understanding and practice in designing annotation purposes.
References
<<<Unit 1 Overview||| Next Lesson (2.1)>>>
- ↑ <https://learn.hootreading.com/blog/comprehension-strategies-making-meaning-of-texts-part-two/ref>