Lesson 1.1: Introduction to Common Annotation Practices
<<<Unit 1 Overview||| Next Lesson (1.2)>>>

Objective and Materials
- Objective: Identify common techniques educators have used to teach annotation practices.
- Materials: Personal Journal, sectioned and labeled Lesson 1.1 Notes
Task 1: Spark Your Thinking

How often do readers examine the efficiency and accessibility of the notes they take, when reading usually occurs organically, and without preparation? You will explore an annotation sample to begin your engagement with the various methods of note-taking that exist most commonly in ELA classrooms. This will begin your examination of the efficiency of common annotation strategies.
- Review the sample ELA annotation to the right, created by New Visions Public Schools as an online reference for annotating a text with purpose.
- In your journal, complete a list of two efficient strategies conducted in the annotation sample, and two suggestions for improvement in annotation and note-taking.
- Complete the question in the same space:
- How many of these 'annotation purposes' listed in the sample do you recognize and utilize as an ELA instructor? How many have you used as a student?
Task 2: Annotation Overview

Annotation and note-taking had not always been a direct skill aimed to be taught in K-12 classrooms, but in the recent decades, the data and research aimed at searching for metacognitive and self-reliant reading strategies support the rise in note-taking instruction.
Jennifer Gonzalez in her article Note-taking: A Research Roundup[3] comments, "Whether it’s taking notes from lectures (Kiewra, 2002) or from reading (Rahmani & Sadeghi, 2011; Chang & Ku, 2014), note-taking has been shown to improve student learning". Gonzalez summarizes, based off decades of research, that explicit instruction on written and visual annotation strategies improves retention and comprehension of information.
- Review Jennifer Gonzalez' blog post Note-taking: A Research Roundup and jot down two benefits to note-taking, as described by the author. Notes in your journal should be composed in a manner that best suits you for our first lesson. Consider your notes in lesson 1.1 a demonstration of your annotation style and demonstration of your thinking as a reader.
Much of the information introduced will be sourced to Beyond the Yellow Highlighter: Teaching Annotation Skills to Improve Reading Comprehension, a journal that is based in data, research and case studies in schools. O'Donnell accurately provides a definition: "Annotating is a writing-to-learn strategy for use while reading or rereading. Annotating helps readers reach a deeper level of engagement and promotes active reading. It makes the reader's "dialogue with the text" (Probst) a visible record of the thoughts that emerge while making sense of the reading" (O'Donnell, P. 82). [4] 2. Review the Annotating Text Bookmark, adopted from Beyond the Yellow Highlighter, on the right hand side.
3. List in your journal the symbols described in the right and what kind of information these annotations signify. Describe the goals of margin notes and post-reading strategies.
4. Watch the following video, Annotating a Text, looking to understand the seven types of annotations, as described by the content creator, HaynesEnglish.
Task 3: Strategies for Marking a Text

Annotations and annotation symbols have become popularized as close-reading strategies meant to highlight specific features of texts. Annotation symbols vary, depending on the genre of the text provided. Symbols used in fictional texts would therefore vary in comparison to symbols used in nonfiction, informational texts.
Annotation symbols have been reworked and rewritten across curricula in America based on changing needs in reading instruction, district and state level standards, and the reading goals developed by educators and school leaders across districts. Specific annotation symbols are developed on a micro-level for classroom specific functions as well, creating a wider variety and deviation in annotation symbols.
Typical annotation symbols/directives to mark-up a text include:
- Star or Underline important points and key details
- Circle words that are not understood
- Bracket/Highlight main idea
- Question mark symbol next to confusing/unclear information
- Exclamation Point symbol next to interesting/shocking information
- Research the following search phrase: ("Middle School ELA Annotation Symbols") into your browser and look into what Annotation Symbols resonate with your experience and learning. Compile examples of annotation symbols you recognize, have used, or would use in your practice as an ELA instructor. Feel free to search for specific annotation practices used in your district, school, etc.
Task 4: Exit Ticket
Now that you have reviewed common uses of annotation in note-taking and the most popularized annotation symbols present in ELA classrooms across America, take a few minutes to complete the following Google Form Survey, as a check of understanding and mode of self-reflection.
The google form is split into two sections:
- Lesson 1.1 Check
- Annotation Self-Reflection
Feel free to jot down your answers to the self-reflection questions in your journal to be able to return and observe your personal understanding, experience and attitude towards annotation instruction in your ELA classroom.
<<<Unit 1 Overview||| Next Lesson (1.2)>>>
Sources
- ↑ https://jenniferfindley.com/annotating-tips-for-close-reading/
- ↑ https://curriculum.newvisions.org/middle-school/find-resources/resource/annotation-ela-sample/
- ↑ Whether it’s taking notes from lectures (Kiewra, 2002) or from reading (Rahmani & Sadeghi, 2011; Chang & Ku, 2014), note-taking has been shown to improve student learning
- ↑ https://www.jstor.org/stable/4128941
- ↑ https://www.teacherspayteachers.com/Store/Ela-At-The-Middle