5.1: Generalizable Language and Transfer
Return to:
Authentic Text as Writing Mentors | Unit 5: Generalizable Language and Transfer
Learning Objective
Participants will review scholarly material on generalizable language and transfer.
Engage
Has there been a time where you were able to figure something out because it was similar to a task that you had completed before? How did you activate that prior knowledge? What effect did it have on the new task? Can you think of more novel situations where you would feel more comfortable as a result? Jot down your reflections on a piece of scrap paper.
Learn
Although Notice and Note by Kylene Beers and Bob Probst describes a close reading protocol, their description of generalizable language is approachable and, well, generalizable to other scenarios. Read Chapters 4 and 5 (pages 80-84) to explore the concept.
This excerpt from "Generalizable Learning: Practice Makes Perfect, but at What?" highlights a critical component in the science of generalization and transfer:
Thus proper characterization of learning must address how different components of learning arise together and manifest at different rates. Practically, this suggests that improper characterization of learning can lead to failures to detect generalization. For example, Kattner et al. showed that, if they had only examined the first few trials in the motion task, then no generalization would be observed, and that averaging over a larger number of trials would reveal generalization but fail to show the change in learning rate.
First, learning rates improve through repeated exposure to a task. Second, how learning is presented must be properly characterized. The author offers this example:
Other examples are more complex, learning to play tennis and squash, or snowboarding versus surfing, involve many areas of task overlap: for example, tennis and squash involve rackets; and snowboarding and surfing involve balancing on moving boards. However, mastering attributes of one task can provide specialized learning that may not transfer, or could even interfere with the other — for example, when there are different racket sizes, court attributes, foot stances, surface properties — and produce negative transfer.
In regards to mentor text and genre, this is why it's important to see connections between similar genres but critical to draw distinctions.
Practice
Use these questions to check your understanding of the readings.
Apply
How might generalizable language be used to help actively engage students in analysis of genre and selection of mentor texts? Post your reflection in the 5.1 Reflection column on the digital bulletin board.