4.2: Unit Alignment Checklist
Return to:
Authentic Text as Writing Mentors | Unit 4: Unit Planning with a Mentor Text
Learning Objective
Participants will confirm alignment between unit essential question, writing task genre, writing task rubric, and mentor text.
Learn
Understanding the relationships between similar performance genres can help streamline a unit and ensure that students develop skills over the course of a unit through different modalities. A genre-based unit, for example, may have direct alignment between readings and task (think of a narrative unit with a narrative writing task at the end), or it may suffer from a lack of mentor text (a short story unit with a literary analysis performance task). A thematic unit generates more opportunity to include a mentor text regardless of task, but only if that is explicitly considered.
A unit obviously includes tasks that lead to the performance task (for the purposes of this mini-course, an extended writing task). Writing two or three shorter tasks and then an essay in the exact same genre may be (which is a kind way of saying "absolutely will be") boring and tedious for students; instead, take advantage of the broad, standards-based genres (informative, argumentative, and narrative) to create a "general" pathway that culminates in student analysis of a directly aligned mentor text and production of a writing task.
Let's take the narrative task from Lesson 2.2 as an example.
Write a myth based on an original pantheon, hero, or culture to explain a natural phenomenon. Your narrative should have a clear beginning, middle, and end, use figurative language as appropriate, and shed light on the values of your original pantheon, hero, or culture.
Rather than assigning a multi-page narrative for every writing-to-create task, minor, genre-aligned tasks could include:
- Writing a narrative paragraph about an important memory
- Rewriting the end or writing an epilogue for a selected myth
- Engaging in a "write and pass" activity where a group of students collectively write a story
- Recording a podcast that tells a family story and explains why it's meaningful
- Write and perform a play or skit
- Write and perform a narrative poem
These, of course, would be in addition to writing-to-respond tasks which would fall under informative or argumentative.
Job Aid
As you review your unit outline, consider:
- Is this a thematic or genre-based unit? Is you unit writing task aligned with the unit essential question, theme, goal, etc.?
- What rubric are you using to assess the unit writing task? If using a custom rubric, are you calling out or weighting particular genre elements (diction, sentence fluency, use of transitional words, etc.)? Are these elements evident in your mentor text, and do you highlight them while teaching the mentor text?
- Does you mentor text model "various aspects of text production including structure, genre, word choice, voice, content clarity, idea development?"
- Is your mentor text enjoyable, accessible, and relevant?
- Does your mentor text "help students find ideas and breathe courage into their writing by helping them take risks and think outside their ‘writing box?’”
- Does your mentor text seamless fit into the unit as both literature to be studied and a model to analyze and emulate?
Feedback
Upload or write your revised unit outline in Google Docs and post a view-only link to the 4.2 Feedback column on the digital bulletin board. If you need help creating a view-only link, please see this video: