Jump to content

3.3: Evaluating Unit Texts to Serve as Mentors

From KNILT

Return to:

Authentic Text as Writing Mentors | Unit 3: Preparing for Unit Planning with a Mentor Text

Learning Objective

Participants will evaluate texts within the unit to serve as a writing mentor.

Engage

Review your reflection from Lesson 2.2 on the digital bulletin board.

Learn

While multiple texts are often covered in a unit, only one or two should function as the mentor text. Beyond wanting to align task and text genre as closely as possible, students should focus on one or texts as a mentor so they will have the opportunity to transfer genre analysis skills later on. Now that you have your unit and writing task set, consider the texts you cover in that unit. Of these texts, do any directly align with the genre of your writing task? Examples might include reading memoirs and writing memories or reading an op-ed and writing an op-ed.

If there is no direct alignment, are any of the genres close? For example, literary criticism is like the grown-up, published version of a literary analysis essay.

If there is no alignment at all, like if students are expected to write a literary analysis paper after a short story unit, would it be valuable to bring in an additional text to serve as a mentor?

Additionally, recall the three basic qualities of a mentor text from the Iowa Reading Research Center blog post:

  • You must think the text is good. It should be enjoyable to for you to read and meet your specific expectations
  • The text must be understandable and accessible for your students. If students are struggling to understand the text from a comprehension standpoint, it will be nearly impossible for them to read the text for aspects of text production including structure, genre, word choice, voice, content clarity, idea development, etc.
  • The text must be relevant to your writing task, as outlined above.

Practice and Apply

Evaluate your mentor text using this organizer as a guide.


Next: 3.4: Mentor Text- Whole Text v. Chunking