3.4: Mentor Text- Whole Text v. Chunking
Return to:
Authentic Text as Writing Mentors | Unit 3: Preparing for Unit Planning with a Mentor Text
Learning Objective
Participants will review strengths and weaknesses of whole text instruction of mentor text, chunked instruction of mentor text, or a combination of both.
Engage
What is the instructional purpose of exposing students to a whole text? What is the instructional purpose of chunking a text for students? Jot down your reflections on a piece of scrap paper.
Learn
Consideration of whole text v. chunked reading of your mentor text really comes down to two factors:
- The length of your mentor text
- The focus of your mentor text
In a genre like short story, there may be considerable variation in the length of the produced text. Depending of grade level, students may produce a short story 1-4 pages in length. A published short story, especially an older text, may extend to 20 pages, which would make focusing on specific aspects of text production such as structure, genre, word choice, voice, content clarity, and idea development difficult. We will return to this concept in Unit 4, but in an example like this, you might choose to read the mentor text purely for comprehension and response early in the unit and return to passages chunked for their relevance to the writing task later on.
You may also want to chunk your mentor text if you have covered elements of a genre earlier on in a curriculum and want to focus on a specific aspect for this unit. For example, let's say you taught argument in an earlier unit and you want to focus on counterclaims in this one. You may want to chunk the counterclaims specifically to help students concentrate on the focal skill.
The main thing to consider when teaching isolated passages is to ensure that students understand the context of the chunked passage they are tackling--remember, the whole point of a mentor text is that it provides students with an example of a socially contextualized communicative event, so we don't want to lose that crucial background.
Practice
Imagine that you are planning to use John F. Kennedy’s speech “Remarks at the Dedication of the Aerospace Medical Health Center” as a mentor text for students. Their writing task is:
Mobile phone technology has made tremendous leaps in only 20 years. However, there are concerns that this technology is generating irreversible changes in our culture, health, etc. What are the benefits of this technology, and are they worth these rapid changes? Write and present a persuasive speech arguing your position.
Your focus for this task is to improve students’ use of counterclaims in the context of a persuasive speech. Given this scenario, what passages would you chunk for students? What would you highlight for their review? Highlight the passages and annotate using the Comment tool.
Access the practice page here.
Apply
Given your unit and writing task, determine whether or not you will need to chunk out passages for your students. If you choose to do so, what will you focus on and why? Post your reflection in the 3.4 Reflection column on the digital bulletin board.