1.2: Distinctive Genre Features
Return to:
Authentic Text as Writing Mentors | Unit 1: Genre-Based Pedagogy
Learning Objective
Participants will identify and evaluate the distinctive features of various genres.
Engage
An easy place to begin thinking about distinctive genre features is genres of fiction. Where does a ghost story fit in relation to other genres? What makes a ghost story distinct from other genres, even similar ones? Use this family tree activity to help you gather your thoughts.
Learn
As you discovered in Lesson 1.1, genre is a multi-faceted concept that includes the traditional definition "types of literature." Because this is usually the most familiar meaning of genre, it is a good place to develop an understanding of what makes different genres distinct and ultimately move towards a deeper understanding of its social, communicative purpose.
Charts like this are a valuable starting point because they isolate what makes a genre unique, even when compared to similar genres. However, resources like these don't dig deeper into the "particular structures or stages and grammatical forms that reflective the communicative purpose of the genre." You can quickly recall that a fable is short story, often with animals as main characters, that concludes with a moral, but the story would no longer feel like a fable if it was told in flowery prose and placed great emphasis on description of the setting. Understanding of a genre's distinctive features, therefore, is a analysis not just of What is told, but How it is told; the How is foundation of the genre-based approach.
Review this excerpt from Almeciga and Evans, 2014:
One particularly adequate method of addressing poor writing comes in the form of the mentor text, or a piece of writing that is observed and analyzed so that students may attempt to imitate one or more linguistic functions. The concept of the mentor text is driven by the notion that good writing spawns good writers as writers emulate and incorporate that which they observe in well-written texts (Cairney, 1995; Graham & Perin, 2007; Mendez Newman, 2012; Oczkus, 2012; Zuidema, 2012). As such, the use of mentor texts may seek to remedy writing difficulties within various aspects of text production including structure, genre, word choice, voice, content clarity, idea development, and so forth (Oczkus, 2012; Robb, 2011).

Analysis of the How, outlined by Almeciga and Evans, aligns with the categories in the 6 Traits of Writing, so if that is a tool, rubric, or approach that you use in your classroom, it can be a valuable reminder for genre analysis as well. These features are informed by the socially contextualized, communicative purpose of the genre. Let's work backwards using the fable example.
- Audience: Children
- Purpose: To teach a lesson on morality or social expectations to ensure cultural homogeny
- Literacy Genre Legacy: Fiction, Traditional literature and folktales
- Defining Features: Moral or lesson is directly stated at the end, characters have generic names like Fox and Crow (Ideas)
- Language Features: Simple plot structure and short length (Organization); clear, simple language with a didactic tone in 3rd person (Voice); low-level, accessible vocabulary (Diction); simple, declarative sentences that can easily be read aloud (Sentence Fluency)
Therefore, fables use simple language and animal characters to transmit societal norms, rules, and expectations to children. They must be short so that they are easily digestible and memorable. Fables are distinct from folktales because folktales are meant to entertain a range of ages while fables are meant to teach children specifically. Fables are also distinct from myths because they teach social expectations but do not convey creation stories or bear religious significance.
Practice
Let's return to the ghost story example for practice. What are the distinctive features of a ghost story? How is it different from similar genres?
Use this document to organize your thoughts. If you would like to review examples of ghost stories, you can check out "The Green Ribbon" and "The Big Toe".
Apply
What genre is the writing task in your unit outline or plan? What are the distinctive features of that genre and how do they support the socially contextualized purpose of the genre? Post your reflection in the 1.2 Reflection column on the digital bulletin board.
Next: Unit 2: Mentor Texts