1.1: Genre-Based Pedagogy
Return to:
Authentic Text as Writing Mentors | Unit 1: Genre-Based Pedagogy
Learning Objective
Participants will read scholarly texts on the principles of genre-based pedagogy.
Engage
Imagine that you have two menus from different restaurants sitting in front of you. The first is a Chinese takeout menu. The second is from a restaurant that is labeled as "New American Cuisine" and has a $$$$ rating on Yelp. What would you expect these menus to look like? What is the purpose of a menu? How does the layout of a menu satisfy its purpose?
Use this survey to organize your thoughts.
Learn
Given a socially contextualized purpose, we approach language with certain expectations. In the menu example, you could probably picture the basic layout without specifics. You would expect a newspaper-sized sheet from the Chinese restaurant without menu descriptions (it's up to you to know the difference between Sesame Chicken and General Tso's!) with dish names left-justified and the price right-justified within a column. A fancier place means that the dish description will probably be found one line below the dish title, indented, and italic. You would never expect to see multi-sentence long descriptions, but instead a fragment that reads like a line of poetry ("Braised beef medallions in a pomegranate vinegar reduction over a bed of wild rice pilaf"). These expectations serve the social, communicative purpose of the genre--letting people know what food is served at a restaurant.
Nunan describes genre as "a purposeful, socially constructed, oral or written communicative event... Different genres are characterized by a particular structure or stages, and grammatical forms that reflect the communicative purpose of the genre in question." Social contextualization is a critical point here; language exists to communicate and communication is an inherently social event. Language must meet social expectations in order to fulfill its purpose. In the menu example, a lengthy description of each dish would be burdensome to the purpose (helping the customer select a meal to order). Similarly, a common location for price on a menu is valuable for economic consideration, whereas a menu without prices expects an audience whose decision-making will be unaffected by price.
Genre-based pedagogy, therefore, is a framework for language instruction using a particular genre as an example. The framework supports student writing through a systematic approach based on generalizable principles.
Watch this mini-lecture to build a mental model.
Read Dirgeyasa's "Genre-Based Approach: What and How to Teach and to Learn Writing" to explore the historical definition of genre and to review a synthesis of genre-based pedagogical research.
Recommended Outside Readings:
The Dynamics of Writing Instruction by Peter Smagorinsky, et al.
Second Language Teaching & Learning by David Nunan
Practice
Use this quiz to check your understanding.
Apply
How has reviewing literature on genre-based pedagogy informed your understanding of what genre is? What new insights has it brought you? What did the reading confirm for you? Post your reflection in the 1.1 Reflection column on the digital bulletin board.