Jump to content

Unit 2: Alternative Counting Systems – Egyptian & Babylonian

From KNILT

Learning Objectives

By the end of this unit, participants will be able to:

  • Explain the structure of the Egyptian and Babylonian counting systems. Convert numbers between base-10 and base-60 representations.
  • Analyze the cultural factors that shaped the development of each system.
  • Compare the advantages and limitations of the Egyptian and Babylonian number systems.

Introduction

We've previously looked at the origins of the number system we often use today, the Hindu-Arabic Numeral system. We've seen how this system, with the place-value notation combined with the use of zero, suits the needs of the increasing complexity of information circulating in our society.

But what about other number systems? Are there societies or cultures who may have found benefits from utilizing a system other than the decimal system we commonly use today?

In this unit, we will look into the number systems of some of the earliest civilizations in history, the Egyptian and Babylonian empires.


We will examine considerations from Jeff Suzuki's "A History of Mathematics" (2002) where the roots of counting for Egyptian civilization around the Nile River and for Mesopotamian civilization around the Tigris-Euphrates are explored.

Egyptian Number System

The Egyptians, with hieroglyphic symbols, employed a tally system for counting. Tally systems typically involve an additive notation where various symbols, which represent distinct values, are combined together to represent a total, or the sum of the values of each symbol.

This shares similar qualities to Roman Numerals, as we have seen in the previous unit, with each symbol representing a value and symbols being combined to produce various numbers. It also shares similarities to how we denote specific values to various U.S. coins, and combine them to represent a total sum.

Read the beginning of Chapter 1 from "A History of Mathematics" (2002) by Jeff Suzuki to see what factors might have led to the development of this system.

Egyptian writings on papyrus, leather, and cloth, although cheap flexible and easily transported and stored, were unable to stand the test of time. So the oldest known recordings of ancient Egyptian mathematics were those carved in stone and preserved over time, exemplified by writings which can found on pyramid walls. Suzuki highlights how the creation of the pyramids itself must have been an undertaking involving a high degree of mathematical proficiency. The Egyptians use of Hieratic symbols may be one of the earliest efforts to make counting and arithmetic more efficient.

Babylonian Number System

The Babylonian number system is unique in that it is a Base-60 number system as opposed to the Base-10 we are familiar with in the decimal system. The Babylonian number system employs cuneiform writing to produce two distinct symbols (one symbol for 1 and one symbol for 10) and uses positional notation where the positions differ by powers of 60.

Read the start of Chapter 2 from "A History of Mathematics" (2002) by Jeff Suzuki to see some unique qualities of this system. As you read this second chapter, keep in mind qualities of the Egyptian number system and see how the two compare.

With mud and clay tablets being the primary method of writing for Babylonians, there is an abundance of recordings which can still be examined today. We see some similarities to the Egyptian number system, such as how each repeats number symbols to indicate larger numbers. However, the Babylonian system, similar to ours, makes use of positional notation. While it brings many advantages, a disadvantage for the Babylonian number system was that without symbols to indicate the position of the units place, the symbol for 1 could also represent values such as 60, 3600, or fractions like 1/60 and 1/3600 , and thus context is necessary to correctly read cuneiform numbers.

How do they compare?

It can be seen that each of these number systems shares some similarities to the decimal system we use today, as well as some unique qualities that are distinct to the needs of their respective civilization. To get a deeper look into some of the historical factors that led to the development of these systems, watch this video by Made in History which explores their creation and characteristics.

https://youtu.be/PXvyG40cCq4

The Babylonians, as exemplified by their numerous mathematical clay tablets, were very keen on performing measurements and calculations, so the use of a Base-60 number system seems fitting as 60 is the smallest number which can be evenly divided by the first six numbers (1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6)

The Egyptians, with heavy administrative tasks and constructions, employ a number system seemingly suited for documenting information in the tally system with various symbols for fast inscription.

Questions

What are some common characteristics of the Egyptian and Babylonian number systems? Are there qualities which one system has that the other does not? Why do you think that is the case?

Are there any characteristics or qualities of these number systems which you may see in the decimal system we use today? Do they provide us benefits today? Why or why not?