Talk:Chris Compson's Portfolio
Instructor comments on your needs assessment and objectives -- Jz833665 10:23, 17 October 2010 (EDT)
Online collaborative writing is a really nice topic to work on. You've done informative analysis of the needs and learner that will inform your next steps.
Here's a good reference for you, http://edu.haifa.ac.il/personal/gsalomon/Computers%20and%20writing.pdf You may particular read the section about new environments such as CSILE (now Knowledge Forum that is often used in my research).
You currently identify "desire to incorporate collaboration in the classroom" as a prerequisite. I suggest that your course include a component to address the desire/attitude issue too, so that the participants will understand the benefits/necessity of collaborative writing online.
Nice work!
Instructor comment on your ICM -- Jz833665 09:40, 3 November 2010 (EDT)
Your task analysis seems very helpful for your design. A few issues to consider:
1) I guess the "desire to incorporate collaborative writing..." needs to be addressed in your course (unit 1) instead of assuming that participants with carry it with them when they enter this course.
2) What do you mean by "scaffolded lessons?"
3) I guess it is very hard to incorporate CW into "an existing lesson plan" without substantial redesign; therefore your unit 2 and 3 won't be so much different. Do you think this might be an issue?
Re: Instructor comment on your ICM -- Christopher Compson 18:30, 14 November 2010 (EST)
Thank you for the feedback. In considering you suggestions and questions, I am thinking of having unit one simply focus on the idea of collaboration/collaborative writing in general. The unit objective would be to "define and determine the norms of collaboration necessary in a k-12 classroom by engaging in discussion and creating a behavioral rubric." This would then make unit two focused on examining Online Collaborative writing environments and unit three would be a culmination of these two units focused on creating a unit of study using online collaborative writing environments. Please let me know your thoughts concerning these modifications before I move forward.
Re: Re: Instructor comment on your ICM -- Jz833665 22:21, 14 November 2010 (EST)
Below is a refinement of your thoughts proposed above:
Unit 1: benefits of incorporating collaborative interactions in writing classrooms (addressing issues related to why and what) Unit 2: how? (specific ways, supported by what online tools) Unit 3: designing a lesson... Reflection
Just for your consideration.
Re: Re: Re: Instructor comment on your ICM -- Christopher Compson 11:06, 15 November 2010 (EST)
Thank you for the feedback. This was how I envisioned the progression in lieu of your first considerations. Should I reflect these changes is my portfolio page or simply modify the unit?