Jump to content

Talk:Ashley Setter's Portfolio Page

From KNILT

Comments on your needs assessment and objectives -- Jz833665 21:10, 16 October 2010 (EDT)

Ashley-

You've chosen a very important topic that will benefit teachers. Your work for the needs assessment and performance objectives is very helpful and will inform your next steps. Three suggestions: 1) I guess the learning outcomes need to additionally include an attitude-related aspect: to recognize the reason and possibility for a teacher to carry out research.

2) The following objective needs to be adjusted: data analysis strategies vary, and do not always count "how many" or based on categories. You may use more general words such as: analyze their data using methods that are proper for their research question....

5. Students will analyze their data by recording how many total things were recorded, how many categories there are, and how many things in each category; in written form using an essay. 

3) Data per se do not tell us what actions to take. It is the reflection of the teacher that does the work. You may want to highlight teacher reflection throughout this mini-course.

A nice start!

Re: Comments on your needs assessment and objectives -- Ashley Setter 17:51, 18 October 2010 (EDT)

Thank you for your comments.

1. My first objective (From personal experience and interest, students will choose 1 area in their teaching/classroom that they would like to change/improve (evidenced by finding research on that topic)) was written to incorporate attitude. Looking at Gagne’s table 7.1, I used the capability verb of ‘chooses’ and explained how the objective is evidenced. I tried to say that the student would need the desire to change or improve something, but do not think I did that! Can you give me a bit more guidance on how to change it?

2. You make a good point for adjusting the data analysis objective; I had not thought about how everyone cannot “count how many”. It is now changed. Thank you.

3. I see your point about continuous reflection; I think it is important to have discussions about each step and I added/changed that in my objective.

Thanks again for your help! I look forward to hearing back from you about your thoughts on my attitude objective.

Ashley

Re: Re: Comments on your needs assessment and objectives -- Jz833665 20:56, 25 October 2010 (EDT)

"From personal experience and interest, students will choose 1 area in their teaching/classroom that they would like to change/improve (evidenced by finding research on that topic)"

Yes, the use of the word "choose" points to an attitude-related outcome: a need for change. But this attitude may or may not relate to action research (e.g., a teacher may make a change without engaging in any action research). Here's an example (only):

From personal experience and interest, students (SAY "PARTICIPANTS") will choose 1 area in their teaching/classroom that they would like to change/improve and summarize the benefits of doing action research in developing a solution.

Instructor comment on your ICM -- Jz833665 22:12, 2 November 2010 (EDT)

The task analysis you've done looks helpful for this project. Two suggestions:

  1. Analyzing prerequisites for each target learning objective (course-level objective) means to identify more specific objectives that will be address in your units. Probably some of the target objectives involve more than one prerequisites. Clearly list them out. For example, data analysis will involve categorizing of qualitative data and basic statistical analysis. Since you're not using a visual map, you may number these prerequisites, e.g., objective 3.1, 3.2... for objective 3.
  2. Double-check the consistency between the unit-level objectives and those identified as your prerequisites. Your unit-level objectives should correspond to the prerequisites you've identified.
  3. Your unit 1 addresses objectives related to the definition and steps of action research too.