Lesson 2: Differentiating between fixed and growth mindsets
Back to course home page: Growth Mindset and Confidence
Back to Lesson 1: Lesson 1: Defining fixed and growth mindsets
Photo retrieved from Education Week
Classroom Situations
So now that you're familiar with what defines fixed and growth mindsets, can you identify them in your students?
Begin by reading the situation below:
Taryn is an eighth grade student. Mrs. Polly, her math teacher, announced to the class that they will be starting a new unit about solving algebraic equations. "This was so hard last year. Our math teacher was terrible so I'm not good at solving equations," Taryn said. Mrs. Polly told her not to get discouraged yet and to keep an open mind because they would be reviewing the process they learned the previous year. As they worked through the first problem, Mrs. Polly called on different students around the room to help with each step. When it was Taryn's turn, she couldn't come up with the correct answer. "I don't care," she said. "I don't remember how to do this and I'll never be good at it anyway." For the rest of the class, Taryn refused to follow along or take any notes and sat with her head down on her desk.
Taryn is operating with a fixed mindset. She has come in with the predisposition that she is bad at this area of math and doesn't bother to try since she doesn't see herself improving. Her ability with this process last year was evidence that she isn't capable.
Now let's see how this situation would be different if Taryn had a growth mindset:
Taryn is an eighth grade student. Mrs. Polly, her math teacher, announced to the class that they will be starting a new unit about solving algebraic equations. "This was really hard for me last year. I had a tough time learning the way it was taught last year but I'm ready to try it with a new perspective." Mrs. Polly applauded her for her open attitude. As they worked through the first problem, Mrs. Polly called on different students around the room to help with each step. When it was Taryn's turn, she couldn't come up with the correct answer. "I just don't remember how to do this," she said. "If I see a few more problems I'll get better at it." For the rest of class, Taryn followed along with the notes and tried to think her way through the problems.
This is an example of a growth mindset because Taryn sees her ability as changeable. She has the perception that if she works on solving problem and gets more practice, she will improve and be more successful.
Classify an Example
Read one more classroom example. Reflect on whether it exhibits a fixed mindset or a growth mindset and which evidence supports it. When you have finished, scroll down to see an explanation.
Chris hasn't handed in any of his science homework for the second marking period. After failing the first quarter, he stopped studying for tests or completing projects. Since his grade is already so low, he feels it's pointless take any notes. Because of this, he's lost during new lessons. Chris thinks that since he doesn't understand it now, he'll never understand science and has stopped following along altogether.
Chris has a fixed mindset toward science. After seeing that he failed the first marking period, he has the outlook that he is just bad at science and won't try anymore because nothing will change his ability. This mindset causes him to put even less effort in and ruin his grade even more, which eventually leads to him giving up entirely. He doesn't think he is capable of succeeding so why bother trying?
Move on to Lesson 3: Promoting a Growth Mindset
