Jump to content

3.1: Thematic v. Genre-Based Units

From KNILT

Return to:

Authentic Text as Writing Mentors | Unit 3: Preparing for Unit Planning with a Mentor Text

Learning Objective

Participants will compare unit development based on theme v. genre.

Engage

Do you currently create your own curriculum or follow curriculum pacing dictated by school or district? If you teach Reading or ELA, do you teach genre-based units (think Short Story Unit, Poetry Unit, etc.) or thematic units (think Community, The Thrill of Horror, etc.)? Why?

If you teach a subject outside of ELA, how often do students produce extended writing tasks, and what is their purpose in writing? What domain-specific skills or strategies do you want your students to develop? Why?

Jot down your reflections on scratch paper.

Learn

The debate around thematic v. genre-based units has existed for a long time and is ongoing. Both sides of the debate have their celebrity all-stars like Lucy Calkins (of Units of Study fame) or Carol Jago, but ultimately, the choice comes down to the teacher. When either is done well, it generates opportunities for students to expand their thinking in a structured, orderly way; conversely, glaring holes are quickly discovered in a lax version of either approach. A curriculum (as a series of units) may be exclusively thematic, exclusively genre-based, or a combination of both.

Read What Thematic Curriculum Looks Like & Why It Is So Powerful by Terry Heick and CCSS and Units of Study: To Theme or Not to Theme by Dr. Timothy Shanahan.

Practice

Respond to this poll to share your thoughts.

Apply

How does the decision between a thematic or genre-based unit affect the selection and evaluation a mentor text? Post your reflection in the 3.1 Reflection column on the digital bulletin board.


Next: 3.2: Unit Writing Tasks